There are two popular kinds of inexpensive solar filters which you can buy in unmounted sheets, cut them and mount them yourself. The older kind is the black polymer type, with the most famous kind (especially in the US) being the one that Thousand Oaks makes (their glass filters are also popular), while the currently more popular (at least in Europe) type is Baader’s Astrosolar safety film. I have used the Baader film for a few years, but thought I’d give the Thousand Oaks a try in case it gives me something the Baader does not.
You can get the Thousand Oaks filter directly from the US manufacturer, or you can find a bit cheaper sheets on amazon.co.uk, amazon.com or ebay (starting at around $15/£14 for a 6″x6″ sheet). The Baader film can also be found on amazon.co.uk, amazon.com, FLO and ebay with prices starting at around £20/$37 for an A4 sheet. Be careful, we are talking here about the “visual” (ND=5.0) Baader film, as there is also the photo version (ND=3.8) which is only for high-power photo use (or visual with narrowband filters) – for a test with that filter check here.
Both materials are relatively easy to cut with scissors. Don’t worry if the baader film looks crumbled when you mount it, you are not supposed to tighten it, that’s how it should be. The black polymer seems like a tougher material, but as I’ve never had the Baader tear on me with some reasonable handling, I wouldn’t say it is too sensitive. It is always recommended to check your filters for holes before your session in any case – this particular Baader hasn’t developed any in the 3-4 years I’ve been using it.
The biggest difference when you see through these two filters is the color of the Sun:
The Baader film gives you a neutral white color. Although it seems a bit “unnatural” to most, it is, in fact, the actual color of our Sun – daylight is white indeed. The black polymer gives a warm orange color, which might not be “correct”, but as it looks a bit like a setting Sun, it is appealing to many observers. However, the black polymer is much darker as well, you will notice from the camera settings about 16x times more light passes through the Baader film just in the yellow-red spectrum, even more in the green-blue. The result is that the Thousand Oaks filter feels a bit too dim on small apertures, from my experience to enjoy a bright full solar disk you’d need about 4 inches aperture or more for higher magnifications. What’s worse for the black polymer is that apart from dimmer the image is also less clear. In fact, on the 80 ED you can easily tell the difference in detail even at low magnifications, while on a 4-inch or larger aperture at least when viewing the full disk the black polymer looks sharp as well and you have to increase magnification to tell the difference.
High magnification and Photography
Switching to higher magnification, even on larger scopes where the Thousand Oaks does fine for full-disk viewing, puts the Baader at an advantage as it shows the sunspots much clearer, better defined and starts to show a bit of granulation, although without extra help from filters (as we have seen in a comparison test) granularity is not easy to see. Well, the Thousand Oaks does even worse in granularity and other features, as even prominent sunspots are less sharp. What’s more, since the black polymer blocks most blue and green light, you don’t have the option to use the most interesting filters (like the Continuum, or the O-III), although the CLS filter does seem to help a bit like it does with the Baader. If you are stuck with a black polymer filter, taking a few hundred or thousand frames, stacking the best and doing some wavelet sharpening will give you perhaps pleasing results, but still in comparison they lag behind the Baader filter:
I think it is clear from the above quick write-up that there really is no reason to choose the black polymer filter, especially if you have a small scope, or are interested in photography, or are after high magnification detail views/photos. Sure, the orange color is a bit more pleasing for some, as it reminds you of a “sunset” Sun, but for just a bit higher price the Baader will give you clearer, brighter views or photos and can be combined with various other filters.
If you want high magnification photography of the sun, take a look at my Astrosolar ND3.8 photo film review.
Note that Thousand Oaks has released a couple of newer filters since this write-up, for which I can offer no comment as I haven’t seen them in action.